Complete 2025 NFL Draft P Rankings:

You are currently viewing our punter rankings for the 2025 NFL Draft. After a really solid punting class last year, can anyone in this year’s class stack up?

Our top punter prospects are selected after thousands of hours carefully scouting the most talented special teamers in college football. Even though no more than 3 will get selected in the draft, several more are signed as free agents, and many more receive a training camp invite.

We’ll provide you with inside information to help you know who will be a star, who will be a bust, and which deep sleepers will shock the world.

BNB Football is the best place for in-depth analysis of 2025 NFL draft punter prospects at all levels of college football. To view other positions, follow the links below.

(Last Updated: April 17, 2025)

1. Jeremy Crawshaw, Florida

P | 6’4″ | 198 lbs | 5th Year

Jeremy Crawshaw is an Australian punter with massive leg strength who has developed into an excellent all-around player throughout his time with the Gators.

Crawshaw’s 2023 season saw him lead the country in net punting average, even above 4th round pick Tory Taylor.

While he wasn’t as good statistically in 2024, Crawshaw showcased improved placement on his punts and as good of hang time as anyone in college football. 

He gets the ball off his foot quickly, with a pro style punting technique that won’t need much refinement in the NFL.

Jeremy Crawshaw 2024 Stats

45.7 yards per punt, 25 inside the 20, 4 touchbacks, 37.3% fair catch percentage, 42.4 net average, 71.2% no return allowed, 4.21s avg hang time

2. James Burnip, Alabama

P | 6’6″ | 235 lbs | 4th Year

James Burnip is an imposing presence at the punter position, and he puts his full 6’6″ 240 lbs frame into every kick.

Originally from Victoria University in Melbourne, Burnip will continue the pipeline of Australian punters into the NFL. 

In his 4 years as a starter for Alabama, Burnip not only showed excellent leg strength, but also a knack for directional kicks and seemingly having above-average control of the ball’s bounce along the sidelines. 

Burnip kicks directionally so much that only 15% of his kicks were returned all season, one of the lowest marks in all of college football.

James Burnip 2024 Stats

45.6 yards per punt, 18 inside the 20, 4 touchbacks, 49.0% fair catch percentage, 43.9 net average, 84.3% no return allowed, 4.29s avg hang time

3. Eddie Czaplicki, USC

P | 6’1″ | 200 lbs | 4th Year

Eddie Czaplicki exploded this season for USC, finishing first in the country in net punting average and winning the Ray Guy Award. 

Czaplicki is one of the best punters in the nation at preventing touchbacks. His absurd ratio over the last two seasons of 40 punts downed inside the 20 with only 5 touchbacks is the best in college football for players with at least 30 punts in that time period.

The American punter has an impressive mix of distance, control, and hangtime, and also has some experience with kickoffs dating back to his two years at Arizona State. 

Eddie Czaplicki 2024 Stats

47.8 yards per punt, 25 inside the 20, 1 touchbacks, 34.9% fair catch percentage, 45.3 net average, 69.8% no return allowed, 3.99s avg hang time

4. Kai Kroeger, South Carolina

P | 6’4″ | 220 lbs | 5th Year

It feels like Kai Kroeger has been in college football forever. The 5 year starter finished second in SEC history in career punting yardage, and finished near the top of college football in punting average this past season.

Kroeger has become known as a fake punt specialist, going 7-of-10 passing in his career for 205 yards and 3 touchdowns, while showing legitimately impressive touch on his throws.

Being able to execute fakes is cool, but luckily Kroeger is also solid at his standard punting job. His hang time isn’t quite as good as some of the higher ranked punters, but he has a solid all-around skillset.

Kai Kroeger 2024 Stats

47.8 yards per punt, 18 inside the 20, 6 touchbacks, 29.8% fair catch percentage, 43.7 net average, 61.7% no return allowed, 3.95s avg hang time

5. Alex Mastromanno, Florida State

P | 6’1″ | 240 lbs | 5th Year

After a somewhat mediocre first three years in Tallahassee, something clicked for Alex Mastromanno starting in 2023, and just a year leader he found himself as an All-American. The biggest difference being dramatically improved consistency.

Mastromanno’s claim to fame has always been his incredibly unique ambidextrous punting style. He’ll kick off either foot depending on the situation, and is the best I’ve ever seen at it.

He finished second in the nation in yards per punt this season, showing solid accuracy and usually making things easy for his coverage team. 

Mastromanno’s Australian punting style and overall mechanics will be a problem in the eyes of most NFL teams, and he doesn’t get nearly as good of hangtime as a result.

Alex Mastromanno 2024 Stats

48.6 yards per punt, 17 inside the 20, 2 touchbacks, 31.6% fair catch percentage, 45.0 net average, 54.4% no return allowed, 3.84s avg hang time

Complete 2025 Punter Draft Rankings

RANK NAME SCHOOL AGE HT WT
1 Jeremy Crawshaw Florida 5th 6'4" 198
2 James Burnip Alabama 4th 6'6" 235
3 Eddie Czaplicki USC 4th 6'1" 200
4 Kai Kroeger South Carolina 5th 6'3" 213
5 Alex Mastromanno Florida State 5th 6'2" 247
6 Brendan Hall Montana State 4th 6'8" 235
7 Luke Elzinga Oklahoma 6th 6'4" 215
8 Jesse Mirco Vanderbilt 4th 6'3" 220
9 Joshua Sloan Memphis 5th 6'2" 207
10 Oscar Chapman Auburn 5th 6'3" 206
11 Mason Fletcher Cincinnati 4th 6'7" 205
12 Peter Moore Virginia Tech 5th 6'1" 206
13 Brian Buschini Nebraska 6th 6'1" 245
14 Fraser Masin Ole Miss 4th 6'4" 244
15 Riley Riethman Navy 4th 5'11" 194
16 Lachlan Wilson California 6th 6'3" 193
17 Hunter Dustman South Dakota State 5th 6'4" 225
18 Ivan Mora Wake Forest 6th 5'11" 192
19 Aidan Swanson Clemson 6th 6'3" 163
20 Ryan Heicher Arkansas State 4th 6'3" 228
21 Aaron Trusler Richmond 6th 5'8" 170
22 Josh Green Oregon State 6th 6'1" 212
23 Nick Barr-Mira Mississippi State 6th 6'0" 185
24 Mark Vassett Colorado 4th 6'3" 221
25 Ryan Hanson James Madison 6th 6'2" 229
26 Tyler Pastula San Diego State 5th 6'2" 225
27 Jack Dawson Jacksonville State 5th 6'3" 196
28 Andrew Stokes South Florida 4th 6'6" 229
29 Alec Bevelhimer Miami (OH) 5th 6'2" 214
30 James Evans Indiana 4th 6'1" 219
31 Shelby Pruett Colgate 4th 6'2" 200
32 Bryce Lofton Southern Miss 6th 6'2" 209
33 Michael O'Shaughnessy Charlotte 6th 6'4" 217
34 Andy Day Utah Tech 5th 6'1" 199
35 Mark Crawford Minnesota 5th 6'4" 219
36 Lucas Borrow Hawaii 5th 5'11" 180
37 Callum Eddings Stephen F. Austin 4th 5'10" 150
38 Riley Williams Edward Waters 4th 6'1" 205
39 Jack Culbreath Wyoming 5th 6'4" 242
40 Matt Noll Jackson State 5th 6'0" 200
41 Stephen Kotsanlee Utah State 5th 6'1" 206
42 Daniel Giangrasso Brockport State 5th 6'5" 210
43 Avery Book Akron 5th 5'10" 197
44 Daton Montiel Florida International 6th 6'0" 181
45 Aaron Rodriguez New Mexico 6th 5'11" 191
46 Blake Ochsendorf LSU 7th 6'6" 219
47 Grant Burkett Missouri State 6th 6'1" 175
48 Reed Martin Edinboro 4th 5'10" 190
49 Ruben Anderson William & Mary 5th 6'2" 215
50 Adrian Guzman Tarleton State 5th 6'0" 200
51 Juan Velarde NC Central 5th 5'9" 195
52 George Eberle New Mexico State 6th 5'10" 182
53 Ethan Duane Buffalo 4th 6'1" 213
54 Albert Jang Pennsylvania 4th 6'2" 200
55 Sean Lehane New Hampshire 6th 6'0" 216
56 James Platte Citadel 4th 6'0" 210
57 Parker Dahlman Concordia-St. Paul 4th 6'5" 227
58 Josh Smith Kent State 4th 6'0" 190
59 Aidan Clark Central Connecticut 5th 6'2" 267
60 Kaedin Steindorf North Dakota State 5th 6'1" 200
61 Brian Cooey Ball State 6th 6'2" 185
62 Seamus Hall Old Dominion 4th 6'1" 197
63 Sam Johnson Valparaiso 5th 6'4" 230
64 Mitchell McGarry East Texas A&M 6th 6'4" 220
65 Cameron Welch Texas Lutheran 4th 6'1" 206
66 Kyle Romenick Duquesne 6th 6'1" 223
67 Paddy Turner Colorado State 6th 6'5" 199
68 Zach Haynes Mississippi State 6th 6'1" 195
69 Hunter Villavicencio Fort Lewis 4th 6'3" 188
70 Joshua Hutley Concord 5th 6'0" 200
71 Tighe Hoey Hamilton 4th 6'2" 202
72 Tom Ellard Northern State 4th 6'0" 165
73 Jack Wilson Ohio 5th 5'10" 225
74 David Shanahan Georgia Tech 4th 6'1" 202
75 Dominik Stadlman Austin Peay 5th 6'2" 165
76 Trey Turk Mid Tenn State 4th 6'1" 210
77 Andrew Toler Rose-Hulman 5th 6'2" 205
78 Scotty Roblow Northwestern State 6th 6'5" 180
79 Isaac Pearson SMU 5th 6'1" 224
80 Tom Foley Northern Illinois 6th 6'4" 235
81 Brennen Schmitt West Virginia State 4th 6'3" 183
82 Jack Brady Campbell 6th 5'11" 200
83 Brady Hodges Louisville 4th 6'1" 200
84 Parker Janky Fort Hays State 4th 5'10" 170
85 Dyson Roberts South Carolina State 5th 5'11" 190
86 David Chapeau Central Michigan 6th 6'1" 246
87 Ethan Klapatch Millsaps 4th 6'1" 188
88 Conner Maynard Appalachian State 6th 6'2" 170
89 Davis Golick Dartmouth 4th 6'1" 210
90 Jack Martin South Alabama 5th 5'11" 178
91 Carson Bay Air Force 4th 5'11" 165
92 Ben Banks-Altekruse UC-Davis 5th 6'1" 210
93 Logan Kobus Minnesota-Duluth 4th 6'4" 225
94 Devin Versteegen Winston-Salem State 4th 6'1" 196
95 Riley Stephens Western Kentucky 5th 6'3" 190
96 Cole Peterson Merrimack 5th 5'9" 180
97 Will Hughes Columbia 5th 6'0" 175
98 Cameron Shirangi USC 5th 6'1" 200
99 Josh Plaster Oklahoma 6th 6'0" 185
100 Jakob Trestik Lafayette 5th 5'9" 190
101 Jeremy Baker Arkansas-Pine Bluff 4th 5'11" 185
102 Conor Hunt Rice 5th 5'11" 190
103 Race Mahlum Arizona State 6th 6'2" 185
104 Jordan Doelling Florida International 4th 6'5" 230
105 Cam Guess Pittsburgh 5th 5'11" 205
WordPress Tables

MORE 2025 NFL DRAFT RANKINGS

Traits That Make a Punter Prospect Great

Punter is one of my favorite positions to scout because you get plenty of reps to evaluate. But there’s a lot more to being a punter than just kicking the ball far. Other than distance, you should consider hang time, speed to kick, placement near the end zone, and consistency when scouting the top punter prospects.

Some of the factors we consider when scouting are included below.

Leg Strength

Most importantly, draft eligible punters need to have a very strong leg. Keep in mind that leg strength is a lot more than just having a high punting average, you also need to translate that strength into hang time to prevent returns and avoid outkicking your coverage.

Placement

The best punter prospects are effective with directional punts, able to consistently down the ball inside the 20 yard line, and avoid touchbacks. They need to punt within the system and have good overall accuracy and consistency.

Technique

A lot of college punters use a rugby style, but that doesn’t really fly in the NFL. Future NFL punters need to have a clean, consistent technique to generate power and hang time. They also need to get the punt off incredibly fast to avoid getting blocked.

Holding

It might not be glamorous, but punters are almost always the holder on field goals and extra points. If your punter doesn’t cleanly catch and place the ball, your kicker will struggle. It might not be the hardest part of the job, but some players are significantly better than others.

Overall Opinion of the 2025 Punter Draft Class

This is looking like an above average punting class. Most of these guys are advanced in terms of forcing fair catches and not outkicking their coverages. While the deep depth isn’t any better than average, there are at least 7 prospects with legitimate NFL hopes.