Complete 2025 NFL Draft P Rankings:
You are currently viewing our punter rankings for the 2025 NFL Draft. After a really solid punting class last year, can anyone in this year’s class stack up?
Our top punter prospects are selected after thousands of hours carefully scouting the most talented special teamers in college football. Even though no more than 3 will get selected in the draft, several more are signed as free agents, and many more receive a training camp invite.
We’ll provide you with inside information to help you know who will be a star, who will be a bust, and which deep sleepers will shock the world.
BNB Football is the best place for in-depth analysis of 2025 NFL draft punter prospects at all levels of college football. To view other positions, follow the links below.
(Last Updated: October 29, 2024)
1. Jeremy Crawshaw, Florida
P | 6’4″ | 205 lbs | 5th Year
Jeremy Crawshaw scouting report preview coming soon.
Jeremy Crawshaw 2023 Stats
48.9 yards per punt, 15 inside the 20, 5 touchbacks, 31.0% fair catch percentage
2. Brett Thorson, Georgia
P | 6’2″ | 235 lbs | 3rd Year
Brett Thorson scouting report preview coming soon.
Brett Thorson 2023 Stats
43.8 yards per punt, 14 inside the 20, 2 touchbacks, 65.6% fair catch percentage
3. James Burnip, Alabama
P | 6’6″ | 220 lbs | 4th Year
James Burnip scouting report preview coming soon.
James Burnip 2023 Stats
47.5 yards per punt, 22 inside the 20, 7 touchbacks, 31.0% fair catch percentage
4. Alex Mastromanno, Florida State
P | 6’1″ | 240 lbs | 5th Year
Alex Mastromanno scouting report preview coming soon.
Alex Mastromanno 2023 Stats
45.5 yards per punt, 26 inside the 20, 3 touchbacks, 56.1% fair catch percentage
5. Eddie Czaplicki, USC
P | 6’1″ | 205 lbs | 4th Year
Eddie Czaplicki scouting report preview coming soon.
Eddie Czaplicki 2023 Stats
43.3 yards per punt, 15 inside the 20, 4 touchbacks, 59.1% fair catch percentage
Complete 2025 Punter Draft Rankings
| RANK | NAME | SCHOOL | AGE | HT | WT |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jeremy Crawshaw | Florida | 5th | 6'4" | 205 |
| 2 | Brett Thorson | Georgia | 3rd | 6'2" | 235 |
| 3 | James Burnip | Alabama | 4th | 6'6" | 220 |
| 4 | Alex Mastromanno | Florida State | 5th | 6'1" | 240 |
| 5 | Eddie Czaplicki | USC | 4th | 6'1" | 205 |
| 6 | Mason Fletcher | Cincinnati | 4th | 6'7" | 205 |
| 7 | Kai Kroeger | South Carolina | 5th | 6'4" | 220 |
| 8 | Aaron Trusler | Richmond | 6th | 5'8" | 170 |
| 9 | Jack Culbreath | Wyoming | 5th | 6'4" | 235 |
| 10 | Tyler Pastula | San Diego State | 5th | 6'3" | 215 |
| 11 | Blake Ochsendorf | LSU | 7th | 6'6" | 220 |
| 12 | Matt Noll | Jackson State | 5th | 6'0" | 200 |
| 13 | Hunter Dustman | South Dakota State | 5th | 6'4" | 225 |
MORE 2025 NFL DRAFT RANKINGS
Traits That Make a Punter Prospect Great
Punter is one of my favorite positions to scout because you get plenty of reps to evaluate. But there’s a lot more to being a punter than just kicking the ball far. Other than distance, you should consider hang time, speed to kick, placement near the end zone, and consistency when scouting the top punter prospects.
Some of the factors we consider when scouting are included below.
Leg Strength
Most importantly, draft eligible punters need to have a very strong leg. Keep in mind that leg strength is a lot more than just having a high punting average, you also need to translate that strength into hang time to prevent returns and avoid outkicking your coverage.
Placement
The best punter prospects are effective with directional punts, able to consistently down the ball inside the 20 yard line, and avoid touchbacks. They need to punt within the system and have good overall accuracy and consistency.
Technique
A lot of college punters use a rugby style, but that doesn’t really fly in the NFL. Future NFL punters need to have a clean, consistent technique to generate power and hang time. They also need to get the punt off incredibly fast to avoid getting blocked.
Holding
It might not be glamorous, but punters are almost always the holder on field goals and extra points. If your punter doesn’t cleanly catch and place the ball, your kicker will struggle. It might not be the hardest part of the job, but some players are significantly better than others.
Overall Opinion of the 2025 Punter Draft Class
This is looking like an above average punting class. Most of these guys are advanced in terms of forcing fair catches and not outkicking their coverages. While the deep depth isn’t any better than average, there are at least 7 prospects with legitimate NFL hopes.
